Business

Overpayment Scams and Fake Payment Notifications in Online Selling

For many people, a side hustle starts with a listing: a spare camera, a batch of handmade candles, a piece of furniture photographed on the kitchen floor. The first message from an interested buyer feels like proof that the idea works. It i

For many people, a side hustle starts with a listing: a spare camera, a batch of handmade candles, a piece of furniture photographed on the kitchen floor. The first message from an interested buyer feels like proof that the idea works. It is also the moment at which a particular group of scammers tends to appear. They are not interested in the item. They are interested in the way a seller handles the payment.

The ways the trick works

The Federal Trade Commission has described several versions in its guidance for people who sell items online. In one, the supposed buyer insists on a mobile payment app and sends a fake payment notification, hoping the seller will ship before checking. In another, the buyer claims to have paid twice by accident and asks for one payment to be returned. A third involves a check written for more than the asking price, with a request that the seller deposit it and send back the difference.

The check version works because of how banking timelines operate. According to the agency, the deposited amount appears in the seller’s balance because banks must make funds available quickly, usually within two days, but it can take weeks for the bank to discover that the check is fake and remove the money. The FTC’s example is simple: an item sells for $200, the buyer sends a $500 check, and the seller returns $300. Weeks later the bank takes back the $500, and the seller has lost $300 in cash as well as the item.

The agency also describes a quieter scheme in which the scammer asks the seller to read back a verification code, for example from Google Voice. The scammer then uses it to create a number linked to the seller’s phone, which helps to hide their own identity.

The Better Business Bureau has described the same overpayment pattern in a scam alert for sellers of used items. The buyer offers more than the listed price, for shipping, fees or a supposed policy of the payment service, and then asks for the difference back. Later the check bounces or the online payment is denied, and the seller loses both the refund and the item. The BBB treats an offer above the asking price as a red flag, except in rare cases where several people are bidding for a highly desirable item. It also advises sellers to look closely at payment emails, since scammers imitate well-known payment services using unofficial domains, typos and grammar errors.

Why side-hustle sellers are exposed

People who sell occasionally often lack a routine. A full-time retailer has a process for confirming payment, a business bank account and a team that has seen the tricks before. A person selling after work may be answering messages from a phone in the evening, pleased to have an offer and keen to be a good seller. Speed and politeness, both useful traits in business, are exactly what these approaches exploit.

A routine that fits in a few minutes

The advice from both organisations is practical:

  • Prefer local, in-person sales and accept cash where you can.

  • Never deposit a check for more than the selling price, whatever the reason given.

  • Do not accept mobile payments from people you do not know, and check payment inside your own account, not in an email or screenshot the buyer sends.

  • Wait until money has actually cleared before shipping.

  • Do not share verification codes with anyone, for any reason.

  • Use the protections the selling platform offers, and keep the conversation on the platform where possible.

  • Report problems to the platform, and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or the BBB Scam Tracker, even if no money was lost.

Looking at the buyer’s contact details

One further step is to look at who is actually writing. A buyer who moves quickly from the platform’s messages to a text or phone number deserves a second look, particularly if the number seems to have nothing to do with the location in the listing. A reverse lookup tool such as Searqle offers a free phone number search which, according to the company, returns the likely owner’s name, spam and scam scores, location and carrier information. A seller could enter a buyer’s number and see whether it has been flagged, and whether the region and carrier are plausible for someone claiming to be a local collector.

The limits are important. Many real buyers use numbers with little public information, and scammers often use temporary or borrowed numbers, so an empty or clean result proves nothing. A lookup cannot tell whether a payment is real, which is the part that actually costs money. It describes the number, not the transaction. Results vary by country and can be out of date, and a scam score does not identify the reason it was given. Searqle states that it is not a consumer reporting agency, so results should not be used for decisions about credit, housing or employment. The company provides an opt-out page, and the person searched is not notified, so lookups should be reserved for checking the contact details of someone who has approached you, not for researching private individuals. In practice, the lookup is a prompt to slow down. The rules above do the protecting.

Making it routine

Sellers who do this regularly can build the habits into a short template. A reply that says “I accept cash on collection or payment through the platform only” filters out most of the people who are not genuine. A short written checklist, kept next to the phone or in a notes app, removes the temptation to make exceptions when a buyer is persuasive. And if a transaction does go wrong, quick action matters: contact the bank or payment service at once, report the buyer to the platform and keep a record of the messages.

The point of the exercise

A side hustle is meant to add income, not to put savings at risk. The same patterns that were described in these warnings years ago are still in circulation because they still work on people who are in a hurry. A few minutes of verification before shipping an item is a small cost for a business of any size.

Click to comment

You May Also Like

News

Today we’d like to introduce you to Elisha Foulks. It’s an honor to speak with you today. Why don’t you give us some details...

News

Today we’d like to introduce you to Jermaine Hill. It’s an honor to speak with you today. Why don’t you give us some details...

Technology

Call Annie, a new chatbot app, takes the experience to a whole new level by adding video chat. The app, which is available for...

Music

Amateurs and professionals are increasingly using artificial intelligence (AI) to create new, original music. Users of the social media app TikTok are using AI...

© 2026 Hustle Weekly - All Rights Reserved.

Exit mobile version